Is a katana better than a longsword?

No. The katana is a curved single-edged cutting sword optimised against lightly armoured opponents; the longsword is a straight double-edged sword built to cut and thrust against armour. The katana is the better dedicated cutter, the longsword the more versatile weapon.

Which is heavier, a katana or a longsword?

A longsword is heavier — typically 2.8 to 3.5 pounds against a katana's 2.2 to 2.8 — but it often feels lighter because the cross guard and pommel bring the balance point closer to the hand.

Which sword should a beginner buy first?

A carbon steel longsword with a full peened tang is the most forgiving first serious sword: it cuts, it thrusts, and its handling teaches good habits. A through-tang katana in 1060 or 1095 is the better choice if cutting practice is the goal.

←Back to the great hall

Katana or Longsword: Which One Should You Actually Own

The oldest tavern argument in the trade, answered by geometry rather than loyalty.

They were built for different wars

The katana is a single-edged, gently curved cutting sword worn edge-up, made for a fast draw and a decisive cut against a lightly armoured man. The longsword is a straight, double-edged, cross-hilted sword made for a battlefield full of mail and plate, where thrusting, half-swording and striking with the pommel mattered as much as cutting.

Neither is superior. Ask instead which problem you want the sword in your hand to solve.

Weight and handling, honestly

A production katana of 28 to 29 inches of blade usually weighs between 2.2 and 2.8 pounds. A production longsword of 33 to 35 inches usually weighs between 2.8 and 3.5 pounds. The longsword is heavier and longer, yet it frequently feels lighter in the hand because a cross guard and a heavy pommel pull the balance point back toward the grip.

Point of balance is the number that actually tells you how a sword moves. A katana typically balances four to six inches ahead of the guard, which is what makes it bite so willingly into a cut. A longsword balances two to four inches ahead, which is what makes it change direction so quickly.

Cutting behaviour

The katana cuts beautifully because curvature turns a chop into a slice: the edge travels along the target rather than through it. Against soft targets — mats, bottles, bamboo — nothing is more satisfying.

The longsword cuts well and thrusts far better. The straight double edge means you can strike from either side without rolling your wrists, and the point is designed to find gaps rather than to slice.

What to look for in each

Katana: a through-tang held by bamboo pegs, 1060, 1095, T10 or folded carbon steel, a genuinely hardened edge, and a grip that does not twist. Avoid any katana whose tang is welded, glued or screwed.

Longsword: a full-width tang peened or threaded through the pommel, 1060 to 1095 or 5160 and 9260 spring steel, a guard with no rattle, and a published point of balance.

The honest recommendation

If you want a sword to display, to cut mats with occasionally, and to feel unmistakably iconic in the hand, buy the katana.

If you want the most versatile serious sword a first-time owner can hold — one that thrusts, cuts, and forgives inexperience — buy the longsword.

The wall this cry speaks of

The Long Blades

Asked of the house

Is a katana better than a longsword?: No. The katana is a curved single-edged cutting sword optimised against lightly armoured opponents; the longsword is a straight double-edged sword built to cut and thrust against armour. The katana is the better dedicated cutter, the longsword the more versatile weapon.
Which is heavier, a katana or a longsword?: A longsword is heavier — typically 2.8 to 3.5 pounds against a katana's 2.2 to 2.8 — but it often feels lighter because the cross guard and pommel bring the balance point closer to the hand.
Which sword should a beginner buy first?: A carbon steel longsword with a full peened tang is the most forgiving first serious sword: it cuts, it thrusts, and its handling teaches good habits. A through-tang katana in 1060 or 1095 is the better choice if cutting practice is the goal.

Also cried